Magic Spotlight: Secret Lair had it all: a popular destination, huge prizes, Pro Tour invitations on the line, and the once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for the winner to consult on a Secret Lair drop.
Just days following the completion of the historic city's iconic race, thousands of Magic players flocked to Indiana for SCG CON Indianapolis. There, they sprinted through fifteen rounds of Modern. When the dust settled, the most popular deck in the room had been bested, a series of fresh decks made the Top 8, and Hunter Ovington took down the title and the chance to consult on a future Secret Lair drop. Along the way, we saw some of the most interesting Modern matchups in years and were treated to several great matches and new developments.
Here's how we got there.
Eight for the Pro Tour
While the Secret Lair collaboration stole the headlines, there were eight total Pro Tour invites on the line for the Top 8 competitors at the showdown. As was to be expected, the first day of the event showcased an eclectic collection of decks alongside updated versions of classic decks.
By and large, though, the Orzhov Blink shell utilizing
Here's how the full Top 8 broke down:
- Hunter Ovington (Gruul Broodscale)
- Andrew Bailey (Esper Reanimator)
- Raja Sulaiman (Esper Blink)
- Justin Schabel (Izzet Prowess)
- Burke Methena (Azorius Affinity)
- Christopher Kral (Orzhov Blink)
- Geoff Mullin (Orzhov Blink)
- Ian Starkebaum (Domain Zoo)
Let's meet the Top 8 Modern players at #SpotlightSecretLair. The winner will earn both the trophy, the title, and the right to help shape a future Secret Lair product!
— PlayMTG (@PlayMTG) June 1, 2025
First up: Burke Methena, who led the 700-player field most of the weekend with new-look Affinity! pic.twitter.com/1p4kimVwOJ
In the end, it was the not-all-in Broodscale Combo list that took it down in the hands of Ovington, who defeated Starkebaum's Domain Zoo in the quarterfinals before winning two straight games over Justin Schabel's Izzet Prowess in the semis to punch his ticket to the finals against Andrew Bailey, who awaited on the other side of the bracket. Bailey had been consistently late to dinner thus far, meaning
But it wasn't meant to be in the finals, where Ovington scaled his way to the top and
"I chose Gruul Broodscale because it's a fast combo deck that can grind and go long if it needs to," Ovington explained. "
Neither is the deck's actual namesake combo of
You can find all the Top 8 lists here.
A Mixed-Up Modern Metagame
It's been a bit since we've checked in on Modern, but a breakout card has been found: Voice of Victory has found a home in several decks - highlighted by Boros Energy, the most popular deck in the field.
— PlayMTG (@PlayMTG) May 31, 2025
It's helped Spotlight Atlanta winner @Nick_Odenheimer to a 4-0 start! pic.twitter.com/19NyScl5cQ
Modern was the star of the show in Indianapolis, as longtime players brought their long-time favorite decks or newest loves, with decks ranging from Boros Energy to Izzet Prowess to Amulet Titan.
Then there was Corey Burkhart. If the 2020 Pro Tour Champion from 2020 has a brand (besides being generally gregarious), it's being the master of Grixis. And in Indianapolis, this master went to work—his deep, on-camera run brought him a Top 16 finish at the event.
Is it any surprise that PT winner Corey Burkhart is 6-0 at #SpotlightSecretLair with what cannot be described as anything other than a midrangey Modern Grixis deck? pic.twitter.com/zkri4kIXrQ
— PlayMTG (@PlayMTG) May 31, 2025
He was far from the only player to find success going their own way. In fact, while the top of the Modern metagame looked mostly as expected, almost 200 players—or about a quarter of the field—registered a deck that less than two percent of the rest of the field did.
Boros Energy was the most popular deck in the field, but by the end, it didn't crack the Top 16 (though one Mardu Energy did). Instead, we were treated to a veritable buffet of decks, with seven different decks making up the Top 8 and twelve different lists making up the Top 16.
That included what may have been the breakout deck of the tournament, if not for Ovington's innovative Broodscale Combo list—Azorius Affinity.
"
Looking Ahead
The Magic Spotlight Series in Indianapolis is behind us; the Magic Spotlight Series event in Chiba, Japan, is ahead of us. Coming at the end of the month, a Standard metagame that includes Magic: The Gathering?—FINAL FANTASY? will be showcased at Magic Spotlight: FINAL FANTASY. You can find the full list of Spotlight events here.
Ovington joins the select few who have a Spotlight Series title to their name, and before he'd settled in at home, Ovington was making his Pro Tour plans. Congrats!
We have a winner at #SpotlightSecretLair! Hunter Ovington (Broodscale Combo) defeats Andrew Bailey (Reanimator) in the finals at #SCGINDY!
— PlayMTG (@PlayMTG) June 1, 2025
Congratulations to Ovington, who not only qualified for the Pro Tour but also earned the opportunity to consult on a future Secret Lair! pic.twitter.com/KR39DSxBk9